A team that cares.

NAC Insurance Agency is your go-to destination for all your insurance needs and is based in Amherst, New York.

As an independent insurance agency, we offer a unique advantage in the world of insurance. Our dedicated team is committed to providing tailored solutions for home, auto, life, and business insurance.

We make it easy.

Buying insurance can be stressful and time consuming. Our goal is to help you understand your coverage options, what each policy offers, and suggest the company with the best value for your needs.

What sets us apart is our ability to shop the market on your behalf, ensuring you receive the best coverage options at competitive rates. With a wealth of industry knowledge and a customer-centric approach, we prioritize your peace of mind. Let us simplify the insurance process and find the right policies to protect what matters most to you.

Ongoing support.

Insurance rates keep going up as insurance companies pay out more each year for claims. We provide insurance reviews to make sure your discounts are maximized.

Experience the difference with NAC Insurance Agency – your trusted partner in safeguarding your future.

Simplifying the way you shop for insurance.

We work with 20+ insurance companies to compare coverages and premiums that are right fit for you.

NAC Insurance Agency in New York

Independent Agent vs The Rest.

Instead of just working for one company with limited offerings, we represent dozens of top rated insurers. As your needs expand and change we continue to find the best carriers at the best value.

Features & Services Our Agency Captive Agent Online & 1-800 Companies
Access to multiple companies and wide range of products
Easy switching from company to company without hassle
Unbiased and objective advice Tries to sell & support only their one company Tries to sell & support only their one company
Claims assistance and advocacy Adjusters are often exclusive to the one company No help: You vs. adjuster
Policy service from the same person you bought from To call center You'll likely never talk to the same person twice
When you buy from an independent agent like us, you're supporting local business and your local economy #choicematters #independentagent
Google Rating

Your 5 Star Insurance Agency

The best insurance agency, according to those who matter:
Our Customers

Jessica Blackburn
My insurance broker Dallas was absolutely amazing, if you get her you lucky she was super sweet & professional she answered any questions I had, she's the best and I'm grateful to have her! Thanks Dallas (she deserves a raise)
Isabella Peralta
My experience with Dallas was beyond amazing. She went the extra step every time and I can not praise her enough.
Chelsea Czosek
It was my first time going in my own insurance and Dallas was more than helpful. She answered all my questions and did not make me feel stupid. She took her time to make sure I was happy with the deal. 10/10 reccomend!
LaTeha Summers
Jessica was amazing she went above and beyond for me when I needed her. She’s very patient and understanding I would recommend her to EVERYONE. Keep up the amazing work Jessica.
Nathan Lang
Dallas was great through out the entire process and made it super easy for me to get my auto insurance. Highly recommend to anyone
Izabella Keetch
Dallas Andrakulic was so helpful in providing us with a new auto/renters insurance policy. We were uncertain on many things & she answered all of our questions to our satisfaction. We are very pleased with the customer service!!
Natalia Capellan
Dallas is incredibly personable and great to work with! Dallas made this entire insurance process less stressful than I thought it would be. I’d work with Dallas 10 times over if I had too because of how great this experience was.
Syed Umer
Jessica was amazing, she was able to get me a progressive policy in NYS through NAC, even though progressive themselves werent allowing new policies in NYS. She also helped explain coverages in full and reduced my premium overall by suggesting different things like an accident prevention course. She really went above and beyond for no reason it was wild and slightly uncalled for…
Giuliano Pupo
Will is the best. Hooked me up with a great rate, explained everything thoroughly, and was super friendly! Thanks!
Josh Kowal
AmaIng help! Love the quote I was given and very friendly! Helped me with everything I need and will be referring to others!
Lori S
Extremely easy to deal with. Very prompt with correspondence. Friendly, knowledge and explained everything.
Andrea Vogtli
Jessica was so helpful & extremely knowledgeable regarding policies& different coverages. She saved us a considerable amount of $$ with our car insurance & bundled it all with our home and umbrella policy! We are getting more coverage for less $$ and piece of mind. Thank you again Jessica!!!
We’re here for you

Get started with
NAC Insurance Agency.

Our team of knowledgable agents are experts at finding the right coverage for your needs.

Get started with an insurance quote from NAC Insurance Agency